We Provide Care And Support to Senior Citizens
Compassionate, personalized in-home care services throughout northeastern Illinois, helping clients live safely, comfortably, and independently.
Need care for a loved one? Call now: (224) 463-8227
Free consultation. No doctor’s referral needed. Care may begin within 24–48 hours.
Private Pay vs. Medicaid Home Care
Private Pay vs. Medicaid Home Care: 5 Critical Differences Illinois Families Must Know
Private pay vs Medicaid home care is the most important financial decision Illinois families make when arranging in-home care for a loved one — and most families make it without fully understanding the difference between the two options.
The choice affects who qualifies, how quickly care can begin, which services are covered, and how much control your family has over the caregiver and schedule. Get it wrong, and you could wait months for care that could have started this week — or pay out of pocket for services that Medicaid would have covered.
This guide breaks down the 5 critical differences between private pay and Medicaid home care in Illinois, so your family can make a confident, well-informed decision.
What Is Private Pay Home Care?
Private pay home care means your family pays directly for in-home care services — using personal savings, retirement income, long-term care insurance, or family contributions — without involving a government program.
Private pay gives families complete control: you choose the agency, the caregiver, the schedule, and the specific services. There is no application process, no income screening, and no waiting list. Care can typically begin within 24 to 48 hours of your first consultation.
At Salvation Home Health Care Inc., all of our services are available on a private pay basis. We serve families across Cook, DuPage, Will, Lake, and McHenry Counties who need flexible, high-quality in-home care that starts when they need it — not when a government program approves it.
What Is Medicaid Home Care in Illinois?
Medicaid home care in Illinois refers primarily to in-home care services funded through the Illinois Community Care Program (CCP), administered by the Illinois Department on Aging (IDoA).
The Community Care Program provides eligible seniors with in-home services — including personal care, housekeeping, meal preparation, laundry, and errand assistance — at no out-of-pocket cost to the client. The program is designed as a cost-effective alternative to nursing home placement for older adults who want to remain at home.
To qualify for CCP-funded Medicaid home care, applicants must generally:
- Be at least 60 years of age
- Be a resident of Illinois
- Undergo a comprehensive functional needs assessment by the IDoA
- Meet income and asset eligibility thresholds
The Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH) also oversees licensed Home Services Agencies in Illinois — including both private pay and Medicaid-participating providers. Salvation Home Health Care is a proud affiliate of IDPH, IDHS, and IDoA.
Private Pay vs. Medicaid Home Care: The 5 Critical Differences
Understanding private pay vs Medicaid home care comes down to five factors that directly affect your family’s experience.
Difference 1: Speed of Access
Private pay wins when time matters.
With private pay home care, care can begin almost immediately. There is no application to file, no income verification, no functional assessment, and no waiting list. A family in crisis — a parent just discharged from the hospital, a mother recovering from a fall — can have a professional caregiver at the door within 48 hours of their first phone call.
Medicaid home care through the Illinois Community Care Program involves a multi-step eligibility process. Families must submit an application, complete an IDoA needs assessment, receive an eligibility determination, and then be matched with an approved provider. Depending on local caseloads and waitlist conditions, this process can take weeks to several months.
| Private Pay/Medicaid | d (CCP) | |
|---|---|---|
| Application required? | No | Yes |
| Income screening? | No | Yes |
| Functional assessment? | No (optional) | Yes — mandatory |
| Typical wait time | 24–48 hours | Weeks to months |
Difference 2: Cost to the Family
Medicaid wins for families who qualify — but private pay offers more control.
The Genworth 2024 Cost of Care Survey reports the median cost of home health aide services in Illinois at approximately $35 per hour, translating to roughly $82,000 per year for full-time care. For part-time support — a few hours per day — the annual cost is significantly lower.
For families who qualify for the Community Care Program, Medicaid home care is provided at no out-of-pocket cost. This is one of the most important financial resources available to lower-income seniors in Illinois and is frequently underutilized simply because families are unaware it exists.
However, private pay families gain something Medicaid families cannot easily access: complete flexibility in shaping the care plan. Private pay clients can request specific caregivers, schedule care outside standard program hours, add services on demand, and scale care up or down without going through a program administrator.
Long-term care insurance is a third pathway worth considering. Many policies cover private-pay home care costs when benefit triggers are met—typically two or more activities of daily living (ADLs). The AARP resource on paying for home care provides a useful overview of all payment options available to families.
Difference 3: Service Flexibility and Scope
Private pay offers a wider, more customizable range of services.
The Illinois Community Care Program covers a defined set of services: in-home assistance with personal care, housekeeping, meal preparation, laundry, and errands. The scope is meaningful but fixed. Clients cannot typically request services outside the approved program framework without additional assessments or authorizations.
Private pay home care has no such restrictions. At Salvation Home Health Care, our private pay clients have access to all seven of our service categories:
- Personal Care & Home Health — bathing, grooming, mobility assistance, medication reminders
- Companion Care — emotional support, social engagement, accompaniment to appointments
- Respite Care — planned and emergency relief for family caregivers
- Post-Surgical Recovery — in-home support after hospital discharge
- Disability Support — ADL assistance, community engagement, coordination with therapy teams
- Postpartum Care — newborn support, recovery assistance, postpartum doula services
- Concierge & Lifestyle Support — household management, errands, travel companions, house sitting
These services can be mixed, matched, and adjusted at any time — no program authorization required.
Difference 4: Caregiver Choice and Continuity
Private pay gives families far more control over who provides care.
One of the most consistent concerns families raise about Medicaid home care is caregiver consistency. Through the Community Care Program, clients are matched with approved provider agencies, and caregiver assignments are determined by agency availability and program logistics. Families may have limited ability to request a specific caregiver or ensure that the same person shows up every visit.
For many clients — particularly seniors with dementia, children with disabilities, or individuals who communicate in a language other than English — consistent caregiver matching is not a preference. It is a clinical necessity.
With private pay home care, Salvation Home Health Care matches caregivers based on:
- Personality and communication style
- Language preference (we serve families in English, Spanish, Urdu, and Polish)
- Specific care skills and experience
- Schedule compatibility
You meet your caregiver before care begins. If the match is not right, we find a better one.
Difference 5: Eligibility — Who Qualifies
Private pay is available to anyone. Medicaid eligibility is restricted.
This is the most fundamental difference between private pay vs Medicaid home care: private pay requires no eligibility screening whatsoever. Any individual, at any age, with any income level, can arrange private pay home care services immediately.
Medicaid home care through the Illinois Community Care Program is restricted to:
- Illinois residents aged 60 or older
- Individuals who pass a functional needs assessment confirming they need help with activities of daily living
- Individuals who meet income and asset thresholds set by the program
Additionally, not all disabilities, care situations, or age groups qualify. Families with a child who has disabilities, a 45-year-old recovering from surgery, or a new mother needing postpartum support will not qualify for CCP funding. These situations are well-suited to private pay home care.
For a current eligibility check, Illinois families can contact their local Area Agency on Aging — or call Salvation Home Health Care directly, and our care coordinators will help navigate the right pathway.
Quick Comparison: Private Pay vs. Medicaid Home Care Illinois
| Factor | Private Pay | Medicaid (CCP) |
|---|---|---|
| Who qualifies? | Anyone, any age, any income | 60+, income-limited, assessed |
| How fast can care start? | 24–48 hours | Weeks to months |
| Cost to family | Market rate (~$35/hr in IL) | No out-of-pocket cost |
| Services available | All 7 service categories | CCP-defined scope |
| Caregiver choice | Full control | Limited by program |
| Doctor’s order required? | No | No |
| Income screening? | No | Yes |
| Best suited for | Immediate need, full flexibility | Budget-constrained seniors 60+ |
Can You Use Both Private Pay and Medicaid Together?
Yes — and many Illinois families do exactly this.
A common approach is to use private pay home care during the application and assessment period for the Community Care Program, then transition some or all care hours to CCP funding once approved. This ensures continuity of care without a gap during the Medicaid approval process.
Similarly, some families use private pay to access services that the CCP does not cover — companion care, concierge support, postpartum assistance, or extended overnight shifts — while Medicaid covers the basic personal care and housekeeping hours.
Contact our care coordinators, and we can help you map out a realistic funding strategy based on your loved one’s situation and timeline.
Which Option Is Right for Your Family?
Use this simple decision guide:
Choose private pay home care if:
- You need care to begin immediately — within 24 to 48 hours
- Your loved one is under 60, or does not meet Medicaid income eligibility
- You want full control over caregiver selection, services, and scheduling
- Your loved one needs services outside the CCP scope (postpartum, concierge, disability support, post-surgical)
- You have long-term care insurance that covers in-home care costs
Consider Medicaid (CCP) home care if:
- Your loved one is 60 or older and meets income eligibility requirements
- Cost is the primary limiting factor, and you can wait through the application process
- The services needed fall within the CCP’s approved service scope
- You are planning ahead and have time to complete the assessment process
Consider both together if:
- You need care immediately but expect to qualify for CCP in the future
- You need more services or hours than the CCP covers
- You want private pay flexibility alongside the cost savings of program-funded hours
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between private pay and Medicaid home care? Private pay vs Medicaid home care comes down to eligibility, speed, cost, and flexibility. Private pay is available immediately to anyone at market rates (~$35/hr in Illinois) with no eligibility requirements. Medicaid home care through the Illinois Community Care Program is free to eligible seniors 60+ but requires an application, income screening, and a functional assessment that can take weeks to complete.
Does Medicaid pay for home care in Illinois? Yes, through the Illinois Community Care Program (CCP), administered by the Illinois Department on Aging (IDoA). Eligible seniors receive personal care, housekeeping, meal preparation, laundry, and errand assistance at no out-of-pocket cost. For full eligibility details, visit the IDoA Community Care Program page.
How much does private pay home care cost in Illinois? According to the Genworth 2024 Cost of Care Survey, the median cost for home health aide services in Illinois is approximately $35 per hour. Full-time care averages around $82,000 annually, but families who only need a few hours of support per day pay significantly less.
Can I switch from private pay to Medicaid home care? Yes. Many Illinois families begin with private pay home care while the Medicaid CCP application is being processed, then transition to Medicaid funding once approved. This prevents a care gap during the waiting period.
Is private pay home care better than Medicaid home care? Neither is universally better — they serve different situations. Private pay is faster, more flexible, and available to anyone. Medicaid home care is free for those who qualify but involves more process and restricted service scope. The right choice depends on your loved one’s age, income, urgency, and the specific services they need.
Does Salvation Home Health Care accept Medicaid? Our team can help Illinois families navigate available funding pathways, including the Community Care Program. Contact us to discuss your specific situation, and we will help identify the most appropriate funding approach.
Final Thoughts
Understanding private pay vs. Medicaid home care gives Illinois families the clarity to act—instead of waiting in uncertainty while a loved one goes without the support they need.
If you need care to begin quickly, or if your loved one’s situation falls outside Medicaid eligibility requirements, private pay home care from Salvation Home Health Care can be arranged within 48 hours. Our team serves families across Cook, DuPage, Will, Lake, and McHenry Counties with personalized, compassionate care that starts when you need it.
Schedule a free consultation today →
Salvation Home Health Care Inc., 5432 S Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL 60615
📞 224-463-8227 | 📞 872-235-4093
✉️ Info@salvationhomehealth.org
🌐 salvationhomehealth.org
Serving Cook, DuPage, Will, Lake & McHenry Counties, Illinois IDPH · IDHS · IDoA Affiliated
Leave A Comment